---
title: "CNIL fines a French life insurer €5m for 1.8 million passwords kept in plain text"
summary: "The CNIL’s decision of 12 November, published on 18 November: 1.8 million customer passwords stored unhashed, eight staff sharing one database login, and messages kept since 2010."
url: https://www.thetechbag.com/blog/cnil-fines-5m-euros-plain-text-passwords
format: Note
desk: "Data & privacy"
region: Global
published: 2026-11-20
facts_checked: 2026-11-20
author: TechBag (The TechBag Journal)
tags: ["CNIL fine","CNIL €5 million fine","plain text passwords fine","CNIL sanction mots de passe en clair","SAN-2026-016","GDPR Article 32","GDPR Article 5(1)(e)","password hashing","password storage","Argon2","ORA_HASH","salted hash","shared accounts","data retention","life insurance","France","CNIL password recommendation 2022-100","GDPR fines"]
cover: https://www.thetechbag.com/blog/covers/cnil-fines-5m-euros-plain-text-passwords.png
---

# CNIL fines a French life insurer €5m for 1.8 million passwords kept in plain text

*The CNIL’s decision of 12 November, published on 18 November: 1.8 million customer passwords stored unhashed, eight staff sharing one database login, and messages kept since 2010.*

Note · Data & privacy · By TechBag · Published 2026-11-20 · Facts checked 2026-11-20 · Canonical: https://www.thetechbag.com/blog/cnil-fines-5m-euros-plain-text-passwords

France’s data protection authority, the CNIL, has fined a French life insurer €5m for keeping the passwords to more than 1.8 million customers’ online accounts in plain text, with no hashing at all.[1][2] Its restricted committee also found eight employees sharing one login to a database holding all 1.3 million customers with a live life-insurance contract, and customer messages kept since November 2010. The decision, SAN-2026-016, is dated 12 November and was published on 18 November.[2] No breach was needed: storing passwords in clear exposed everything behind them, the committee wrote, “regardless of whether or not an attacker exploited this vulnerability”.[2]

1.8m

customer passwords stored in clear in the login table

CNIL decision

730,289

of them also in clear in a log of every sign-in attempt

CNIL decision

8

staff sharing one login to the 1.3 million customers’ database

CNIL decision

21 years

login data kept, against the insurer’s own one-year policy

CNIL decision

## What the inspectors found, and how long the fix took

The CNIL was tipped off on 27 December 2023 and inspected the insurer on 14 May 2024. Two months later the company began hashing the passwords with `ora_hash`, without a salt; the committee calls that function obsolete.[2] Oracle documents `ORA_HASH` as a tool to “analyze a subset of data and generate a random sample”, returning a 32-bit number by default: a sampling aid, not a password function.[4] Only on 25 April 2026, after the CNIL’s rapporteur had proposed a fine, did the insurer move to Argon2 with a salt.[2]

**Figure: The passwords stayed in clear or weakly hashed for 23 months after the inspection**

*Steps in the CNIL’s case against an unnamed French life insurer, December 2023 to November 2026*

| Date | Event | Detail |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 27 Dec 2023 | CNIL tipped off | About how passwords and security answers were stored |
| 14 May 2024 | On-site inspection | 1.8 million passwords found in clear |
| 10 Jul 2024 | Old data purged | Message history deleted; monthly purges begin |
| 18 Jul 2024 | First hashing | ora_hash, no salt |
| 17 Mar 2026 | Sanction report served | The rapporteur proposes €9m |
| 25 Apr 2026 | Argon2 with a salt | A state-of-the-art function at last |
| 12 Nov 2026 | €5m fine | No order to comply: already fixed |
| 18 Nov 2026 | Decision published | The company is not named |

Source: CNIL, decision SAN-2026-016 of 12 November 2026 and announcement of 18 November 2026 · as of 20 November 2026, 10:30pm IST

The shared logins were the second failing under Article 32. A generic account to the main customer database, and an administrator account on the tool used to view every table, were shared by the eight members of one team. Only individual accounts, the committee wrote, show who read or changed what after an incident. The insurer says named accounts came in November 2025; the administrator account was switched off on 22 April 2026.[2] The third failing broke Article 5(1)(e) on retention: contact-form messages, some with full IBANs, kept for more than 13 years, and a sign-in log holding data from February 2003 and the passwords of 8,628 customers since July 2019, under a policy that said one year.[2] A charge over weak password rules was dropped, because accounts locked after repeated failed attempts.[2]

## How the CNIL set €5m

The rapporteur first proposed €9m, then €7m. The committee measured the insurer against its whole group, treating them as one economic unit under the EU Court of Justice’s Deutsche Wohnen ruling, and used the group’s gross written premiums for 2025, not the narrower insurance revenue the company argued for. The ceiling was €20m or 4% of turnover. The insurer can appeal to the Conseil d’État within two months.[2] Italy sized its [€805m fine on Meta](https://www.thetechbag.com/blog/italy-fines-meta-805m-euros-facebook-gallery) from turnover too; Korea fined [Samyang ₩552m](https://www.thetechbag.com/blog/samyang-fined-552m-won-forgotten-file-server) for a server forgotten after a migration, and Ireland fined [Tinder €11m](https://www.thetechbag.com/blog/tinder-fined-11m-euros-download-my-data) over its data-download tool.

Our viewCheck yourself

Search every table, including logs, for password columns. The CNIL’s 2022 recommendation says a password “must never be stored in clear”: run it through a specialised, non-reversible function with time or memory cost settings and a random salt of at least 128 bits per user.[3] The decision names Argon2, yescrypt, scrypt and bcrypt among the libraries the CNIL points developers to.[2] Give every person their own database and admin login. And check that the deletion your retention policy promises actually runs.

How we did this

Figures as of 20 November 2026, 10:30pm IST

Every finding, date and figure is from the decision, which we read in French; quotations are our translation; the CNIL’s release gives the same three failings. The CNIL published the decision for teaching purposes and chose not to name the insurer; its sector and staff numbers come from the decision. The tip-off concerned passwords and the answers to security questions; the committee’s findings deal with the passwords. The insurer told the CNIL no security incident had compromised data. “23 months” is our arithmetic, 14 May 2024 to 25 April 2026.

Spotted an error? Write to us; corrections are published at the foot of the piece.

Sources

1. [CNIL: Conservation des mots de passe clients en clair : la CNIL prononce une sanction de 5 millions d’euros (in French)](https://www.cnil.fr/fr/conservation-des-mots-de-passe-sanction-5-millions-deuros) — 18 November 2026
2. [CNIL restricted committee: Délibération SAN-2026-016 (in French), on Légifrance](https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/cnil/id/CNILTEXT000055097962) — 12 November 2026, published 18 November
3. [CNIL: Délibération n° 2022-100, recommandation relative aux mots de passe et autres secrets partagés, §48–49 (in French)](https://www.cnil.fr/sites/default/files/atoms/files/deliberation-2022-100-du-21-juillet-2022_recommandation-aux-mots-de-passe.pdf) — 21 July 2022
4. [Oracle Database SQL Language Reference: ORA_HASH](https://docs.oracle.com/en/database/oracle/oracle-database/26/sqlrf/ORA_HASH.html) — undated page

**Disclosure.** TechBag is a software reseller: it earns when companies buy through it, including from vendors named here. The analysis is TechBag’s own; no vendor paid for or saw this piece before publication. Facts are labelled reported, TechBag count or our view.

**Read this next:** [Italy fines Meta €805m over Facebook’s access to Android photo galleries](https://www.thetechbag.com/blog/italy-fines-meta-805m-euros-facebook-gallery) — How Italy’s regulator set a GDPR fine’s size: €805m on Meta, 0.47% of turnover, over Facebook’s access to Android users’ photo galleries.

Go deeper on TechBag

- [Samyang fined ₩552m: a server left online after a migration leaked 149,767 people’s data](https://www.thetechbag.com/blog/samyang-fined-552m-won-forgotten-file-server) — another regulator’s fine for a basic security failure
- [Tinder fined €11m: its ‘Download My Data’ tool left data out](https://www.thetechbag.com/blog/tinder-fined-11m-euros-download-my-data) — a European regulator’s other GDPR fine this month
- [Privileged access management guide](https://www.thetechbag.com/browse/identity-access/privileged-access-management) — tools that give every administrator a named, logged account instead of a shared one
