Data & privacyNote
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal’s OPEN judgment of 19 November: why it set aside the government’s neither-confirm-nor-deny stance, and how Apple’s five grounds will be heard.
A UK court has put on the record, for the first time, that the Home Secretary has given Apple a technical capability notice. In an OPEN judgment on 19 November, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal found the government had not established that it would damage national security to reveal, “as is the case, that the respondent has given Apple a technical capability notice” (para 44).1 The consequence is practical: much of the hearing on Apple’s five grounds of challenge, and on a parallel claim by Privacy International, Liberty and two individuals, can now be held in public. What the notice requires stays secret, and the tribunal has not ruled on whether it is lawful.1
Section 253 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 lets the Secretary of State give a “relevant operator”, a postal or telecommunications operator, a notice imposing obligations so that it has the capability to give assistance with warrants and authorisations. The Secretary of State must consider the notice necessary and the conduct it requires proportionate, and a Judicial Commissioner must approve the decision. The obligations regulations may specify include ones “relating to the removal by a relevant operator of electronic protection applied by or on behalf of that operator to any communications or data”, and a notice may be given to persons outside the United Kingdom.2 The judgment says there has been no publication of the precise content of Apple’s notice (para 50).1
Apple has not described the notice in public. Its UK support page says it “can no longer offer Advanced Data Protection in the United Kingdom to new users”, so for new UK users ten iCloud data categories, including iCloud Backup, Photos and Notes, stay under Standard Data Protection without the end-to-end option. It adds: “we have never built a backdoor or master key to any of our products or services and we never will.”3
The government argued that neither confirming nor denying (NCND) works only if applied consistently, and that official confirmation differs from media reports (para 32). The tribunal found the government had not applied it consistently. It inferred that briefings reported by The Times and the Financial Times took place and were authorised by ministers, senior officials or special advisers (para 40), and that letting Apple brief the US Vice President and Attorney General without any apparent assurance of confidentiality was a further departure (para 41). Leak investigations were cited without detail; documents explaining the true position were marked “OFFICIAL SENSITIVE”, not “SECRET” (paras 18, 33). The tribunal was told an affirmative answer could be found by typing the question into Google’s chatbot (para 42).1
Nineteen months after Apple’s case was made public, the notice behind it is confirmed
Apple and NGOs v Secretary of State for the Home Department, events as the OPEN judgment records them, April 2025 to November 2026
| Date | Event | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Apr 2025 | Case made public | 7 April 2025: tribunal lets the parties and subject be named |
| Aug 2025 | US: UK ‘agreed to drop’ | 19 August 2025: Tulsi Gabbard’s post, quoted in the judgment |
| Oct 2025 | FT reports new order | 1 October 2025: an order ‘issued in September’, per the FT |
| Jul 2026 | Apple’s second claim | July 2026: the first was dismissed on a change of circumstances |
| Sept 2026 | Hearing | 17 September 2026: OPEN, PRIVATE and CLOSED parts |
| Nov 2026 | Notice confirmed | 19 November 2026: NCND rejected; content stays secret |
Source: Investigatory Powers Tribunal, [2026] UKIPTrib 9 · as of 19 November 2026
Apple’s first two grounds ask whether the power extends to targeted interception outside the UK and whether it can be used to regulate the security or privacy services a technology company offers; they can be decided entirely in OPEN. The third, on consultation, largely can too. The fourth, whether the notice is a disproportionate interference with rights under the European Convention on Human Rights, and the fifth, whether Apple was treated differently from other technology companies, are likely to need evidence heard in secret (paras 46 to 48). The parties expect directions towards a substantive hearing in the first half of next year (para 8).1
Sources
Disclosure. TechBag is a software reseller: it earns when companies buy through it, including from vendors named here. The analysis is TechBag’s own; no vendor paid for or saw this piece before publication. Facts are labelled reported, TechBag count or our view.